Merge "Support GKI boot.img v4 signing"

This commit is contained in:
Treehugger Robot 2021-03-23 00:24:33 +00:00 committed by Gerrit Code Review
commit 30f09a1a2e
5 changed files with 293 additions and 13 deletions

View File

@ -856,6 +856,23 @@ INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS := \
--os_version $(PLATFORM_VERSION_LAST_STABLE) \
--os_patch_level $(PLATFORM_SECURITY_PATCH)
ifdef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH
ifndef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_ALGORITHM
$(error BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_ALGORITHM should be defined with BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH)
endif
INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS := \
--gki_signing_key $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) \
--gki_signing_algorithm $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_ALGORITHM) \
--gki_signing_avbtool_path $(AVBTOOL)
endif
# Using double quote to pass BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_SIGNATURE_ARGS as a single string
# to MKBOOTIMG, although it may contain multiple args.
ifdef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_SIGNATURE_ARGS
INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS += \
--gki_signing_signature_args "$(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_SIGNATURE_ARGS)"
endif
# Define these only if we are building boot
ifdef BUILDING_BOOT_IMAGE
INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET := $(BUILT_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET)
@ -870,7 +887,8 @@ ifeq (true,$(BOARD_AVB_ENABLE))
# $1: boot image target
define build_boot_board_avb_enabled
$(MKBOOTIMG) --kernel $(call bootimage-to-kernel,$(1)) $(INTERNAL_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $(1)
$(MKBOOTIMG) --kernel $(call bootimage-to-kernel,$(1)) $(INTERNAL_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) \
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $(1)
$(call assert-max-image-size,$(1),$(call get-hash-image-max-size,$(call get-bootimage-partition-size,$(1),boot)))
$(AVBTOOL) add_hash_footer \
--image $(1) \
@ -879,12 +897,12 @@ define build_boot_board_avb_enabled
$(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_ADD_HASH_FOOTER_ARGS)
endef
$(INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(AVBTOOL) $(INTERNAL_BOOTIMAGE_FILES) $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH)
$(INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(AVBTOOL) $(INTERNAL_BOOTIMAGE_FILES) $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH) $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH)
$(call pretty,"Target boot image: $@")
$(call build_boot_board_avb_enabled,$@)
.PHONY: bootimage-nodeps
bootimage-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG) $(AVBTOOL) $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH)
bootimage-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG) $(AVBTOOL) $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH) $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH)
@echo "make $@: ignoring dependencies"
$(foreach b,$(INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET),$(call build_boot_board_avb_enabled,$(b)))
@ -2149,8 +2167,8 @@ define build-recoveryimage-target
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(BOARD_RECOVERY_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) \
--output $(1).unsigned, \
$(MKBOOTIMG) $(if $(strip $(2)),--kernel $(strip $(2))) $(INTERNAL_RECOVERYIMAGE_ARGS) \
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(BOARD_RECOVERY_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) \
--output $(1))
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS) \
$(BOARD_RECOVERY_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $(1))
$(if $(filter true,$(PRODUCT_SUPPORTS_BOOT_SIGNER)),\
$(if $(filter true,$(BOARD_USES_RECOVERY_AS_BOOT)),\
$(BOOT_SIGNER) /boot $(1) $(PRODUCT_VERITY_SIGNING_KEY).pk8 $(PRODUCT_VERITY_SIGNING_KEY).x509.pem $(1),\
@ -2178,6 +2196,9 @@ endif
ifeq (true,$(BOARD_AVB_ENABLE))
recoveryimage-deps += $(AVBTOOL) $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH)
endif
ifdef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH
recoveryimage-deps += $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) $(AVBTOOL)
endif
ifdef BOARD_INCLUDE_RECOVERY_DTBO
ifdef BOARD_PREBUILT_RECOVERY_DTBOIMAGE
recoveryimage-deps += $(BOARD_PREBUILT_RECOVERY_DTBOIMAGE)
@ -2353,17 +2374,18 @@ endef
# $(1): output file
define build-debug-bootimage-target
$(MKBOOTIMG) --kernel $(PRODUCT_OUT)/$(subst .img,,$(subst boot-debug,kernel,$(notdir $(1)))) \
$(INTERNAL_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $1
$(INTERNAL_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) \
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $1
$(if $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH),$(call test-key-sign-bootimage,$1,boot-debug))
endef
# Depends on original boot.img and ramdisk-debug.img, to build the new boot-debug.img
$(INSTALLED_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET) $(INSTALLED_DEBUG_RAMDISK_TARGET)
$(INSTALLED_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(INSTALLED_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET) $(INSTALLED_DEBUG_RAMDISK_TARGET) $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) $(AVBTOOL)
$(call pretty,"Target boot debug image: $@")
$(call build-debug-bootimage-target, $@)
.PHONY: bootimage_debug-nodeps
bootimage_debug-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG)
bootimage_debug-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG) $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) $(AVBTOOL)
echo "make $@: ignoring dependencies"
$(foreach b,$(INSTALLED_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET),$(call build-debug-bootimage-target,$b))
@ -2528,17 +2550,19 @@ endif
# $(1): output file
define build-boot-test-harness-target
$(MKBOOTIMG) --kernel $(PRODUCT_OUT)/$(subst .img,,$(subst boot-test-harness,kernel,$(notdir $(1)))) \
$(INTERNAL_TEST_HARNESS_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $@
$(INTERNAL_TEST_HARNESS_BOOTIMAGE_ARGS) $(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS) \
$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_GKI_SINGING_ARGS) $(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS) --output $@
$(if $(BOARD_AVB_BOOT_KEY_PATH),$(call test-key-sign-bootimage,$@,boot-test-harness))
endef
# Build the new boot-test-harness.img, based on boot-debug.img and ramdisk-test-harness.img.
$(INSTALLED_TEST_HARNESS_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(INSTALLED_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET) $(INSTALLED_TEST_HARNESS_RAMDISK_TARGET)
$(INSTALLED_TEST_HARNESS_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET): $(MKBOOTIMG) $(INSTALLED_DEBUG_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET) $(INSTALLED_TEST_HARNESS_RAMDISK_TARGET) \
$(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) $(AVBTOOL)
$(call pretty,"Target boot test harness image: $@")
$(call build-boot-test-harness-target,$@)
.PHONY: bootimage_test_harness-nodeps
bootimage_test_harness-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG)
bootimage_test_harness-nodeps: $(MKBOOTIMG) $(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH) $(AVBTOOL)
echo "make $@: ignoring dependencies"
$(foreach b,$(INSTALLED_TEST_HARNESS_BOOTIMAGE_TARGET),$(call build-boot-test-harness-target,$b))
@ -4326,6 +4350,13 @@ endif
$(hide) echo 'mkbootimg_args=$(BOARD_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS)' >> $@
$(hide) echo 'recovery_mkbootimg_args=$(BOARD_RECOVERY_MKBOOTIMG_ARGS)' >> $@
$(hide) echo 'mkbootimg_version_args=$(INTERNAL_MKBOOTIMG_VERSION_ARGS)' >> $@
ifdef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH
$(hide) echo 'gki_signing_key_path=$(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_KEY_PATH)' >> $@
$(hide) echo 'gki_signing_algorithm=$(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_ALGORITHM)' >> $@
endif
ifdef BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_SIGNATURE_ARGS
$(hide) echo 'gki_signing_signature_args=$(BOARD_GKI_SIGNING_SIGNATURE_ARGS)' >> $@
endif
$(hide) echo "multistage_support=1" >> $@
$(hide) echo "blockimgdiff_versions=3,4" >> $@
ifeq ($(PRODUCT_BUILD_GENERIC_OTA_PACKAGE),true)

View File

@ -1339,6 +1339,35 @@ def AddAftlInclusionProof(output_image):
RunAndCheckOutput(verify_cmd)
def AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd):
"""Append GKI signing arguments for mkbootimg."""
# e.g., --gki_signing_key path/to/signing_key
# --gki_signing_algorithm SHA256_RSA4096"
key_path = OPTIONS.info_dict.get("gki_signing_key_path")
# It's fine that a non-GKI boot.img has no gki_signing_key_path.
if not key_path:
return
if not os.path.exists(key_path) and OPTIONS.search_path:
new_key_path = os.path.join(OPTIONS.search_path, key_path)
if os.path.exists(new_key_path):
key_path = new_key_path
# Checks key_path exists, before appending --gki_signing_* args.
if not os.path.exists(key_path):
raise ExternalError('gki_signing_key_path: "{}" not found'.format(key_path))
algorithm = OPTIONS.info_dict.get("gki_signing_algorithm")
if key_path and algorithm:
cmd.extend(["--gki_signing_key", key_path,
"--gki_signing_algorithm", algorithm])
signature_args = OPTIONS.info_dict.get("gki_signing_signature_args")
if signature_args:
cmd.extend(["--gki_signing_signature_args", signature_args])
def BuildVBMeta(image_path, partitions, name, needed_partitions):
"""Creates a VBMeta image.
@ -1520,6 +1549,8 @@ def _BuildBootableImage(image_name, sourcedir, fs_config_file, info_dict=None,
if has_ramdisk:
cmd.extend(["--ramdisk", ramdisk_img.name])
AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd)
img_unsigned = None
if info_dict.get("vboot"):
img_unsigned = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile()

View File

@ -123,6 +123,17 @@ Usage: sign_target_files_apks [flags] input_target_files output_target_files
mounted on the partition (e.g. "--signing_helper /path/to/helper"). The
args will be appended to the existing ones in info dict.
--gki_signing_algorithm <algorithm>
--gki_signing_key <key>
Use the specified algorithm (e.g. SHA256_RSA4096) and the key to generate
'boot signature' in a v4 boot.img. Otherwise it uses the existing values
in info dict.
--gki_signing_extra_args <args>
Specify any additional args that are needed to generate 'boot signature'
(e.g. --prop foo:bar). The args will be appended to the existing ones
in info dict.
--android_jar_path <path>
Path to the android.jar to repack the apex file.
"""
@ -174,6 +185,9 @@ OPTIONS.tag_changes = ("-test-keys", "-dev-keys", "+release-keys")
OPTIONS.avb_keys = {}
OPTIONS.avb_algorithms = {}
OPTIONS.avb_extra_args = {}
OPTIONS.gki_signing_key = None
OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm = None
OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args = None
OPTIONS.android_jar_path = None
@ -677,6 +691,9 @@ def ProcessTargetFiles(input_tf_zip, output_tf_zip, misc_info,
if misc_info.get('avb_enable') == 'true':
RewriteAvbProps(misc_info)
# Replace the GKI signing key for boot.img, if any.
ReplaceGkiSigningKey(misc_info)
# Write back misc_info with the latest values.
ReplaceMiscInfoTxt(input_tf_zip, output_tf_zip, misc_info)
@ -995,6 +1012,28 @@ def RewriteAvbProps(misc_info):
misc_info[args_key] = result
def ReplaceGkiSigningKey(misc_info):
"""Replaces the GKI signing key."""
key = OPTIONS.gki_signing_key
if not key:
return
algorithm = OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm
if not algorithm:
raise ValueError("Missing --gki_signing_algorithm")
print('Replacing GKI signing key with "%s" (%s)' % (key, algorithm))
misc_info["gki_signing_algorithm"] = algorithm
misc_info["gki_signing_key_path"] = key
extra_args = OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args
if extra_args:
print('Setting extra GKI signing args: "%s"' % (extra_args))
misc_info["gki_signing_signature_args"] = (
misc_info.get("gki_signing_signature_args", '') + ' ' + extra_args)
def BuildKeyMap(misc_info, key_mapping_options):
for s, d in key_mapping_options:
if s is None: # -d option
@ -1226,6 +1265,12 @@ def main(argv):
# 'oem=--signing_helper_with_files=/tmp/avbsigner.sh'.
partition, extra_args = a.split("=", 1)
OPTIONS.avb_extra_args[partition] = extra_args
elif o == "--gki_signing_key":
OPTIONS.gki_signing_key = a
elif o == "--gki_signing_algorithm":
OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm = a
elif o == "--gki_signing_extra_args":
OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args = a
else:
return False
return True
@ -1273,6 +1318,9 @@ def main(argv):
"avb_extra_custom_image_key=",
"avb_extra_custom_image_algorithm=",
"avb_extra_custom_image_extra_args=",
"gki_signing_key=",
"gki_signing_algorithm=",
"gki_signing_extra_args=",
],
extra_option_handler=option_handler)

View File

@ -1670,6 +1670,127 @@ class CommonUtilsTest(test_utils.ReleaseToolsTestCase):
common.OPTIONS.aftl_key_path]
common.RunAndCheckOutput(verify_cmd)
@test_utils.SkipIfExternalToolsUnavailable()
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs_NoSigningKeyPath(self):
# A non-GKI boot.img has no gki_signing_key_path.
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
# 'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
# Tests no --gki_signing_* args are appended if there is no
# gki_signing_key_path.
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
expected_cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
common.AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd)
self.assertEqual(cmd, expected_cmd)
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs_NoSigningAlgorithm(self):
pubkey = os.path.join(self.testdata_dir, 'testkey_gki.pem')
with open(pubkey, 'wb') as f:
f.write(b'\x00' * 100)
self.assertTrue(os.path.exists(pubkey))
# Tests no --gki_signing_* args are appended if there is no
# gki_signing_algorithm.
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
# 'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
expected_cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
common.AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd)
self.assertEqual(cmd, expected_cmd)
@test_utils.SkipIfExternalToolsUnavailable()
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs(self):
pubkey = os.path.join(self.testdata_dir, 'testkey_gki.pem')
with open(pubkey, 'wb') as f:
f.write(b'\x00' * 100)
self.assertTrue(os.path.exists(pubkey))
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
common.AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd)
expected_cmd = [
'mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4',
'--gki_signing_key', pubkey,
'--gki_signing_algorithm', 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'--gki_signing_signature_args', '--prop foo:bar'
]
self.assertEqual(cmd, expected_cmd)
@test_utils.SkipIfExternalToolsUnavailable()
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs_KeyPathNotFound(self):
pubkey = os.path.join(self.testdata_dir, 'no_testkey_gki.pem')
self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(pubkey))
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
self.assertRaises(common.ExternalError, common.AppendGkiSigningArgs, cmd)
@test_utils.SkipIfExternalToolsUnavailable()
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs_SearchKeyPath(self):
pubkey = 'testkey_gki.pem'
self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(pubkey))
# Tests it should replace the pubkey with an existed key under
# OPTIONS.search_path, i.e., os.path.join(OPTIONS.search_path, pubkey).
search_path_dir = common.MakeTempDir()
search_pubkey = os.path.join(search_path_dir, pubkey)
with open(search_pubkey, 'wb') as f:
f.write(b'\x00' * 100)
self.assertTrue(os.path.exists(search_pubkey))
common.OPTIONS.search_path = search_path_dir
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
common.AppendGkiSigningArgs(cmd)
expected_cmd = [
'mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4',
'--gki_signing_key', search_pubkey,
'--gki_signing_algorithm', 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'--gki_signing_signature_args', '--prop foo:bar'
]
self.assertEqual(cmd, expected_cmd)
@test_utils.SkipIfExternalToolsUnavailable()
def test_AppendGkiSigningArgs_SearchKeyPathNotFound(self):
pubkey = 'no_testkey_gki.pem'
self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(pubkey))
# Tests it should raise ExternalError if no key found under
# OPTIONS.search_path.
search_path_dir = common.MakeTempDir()
search_pubkey = os.path.join(search_path_dir, pubkey)
self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(search_pubkey))
common.OPTIONS.search_path = search_path_dir
common.OPTIONS.info_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': pubkey,
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'SHA256_RSA4096',
'gki_signing_signature_args': '--prop foo:bar',
}
cmd = ['mkbootimg', '--header_version', '4']
self.assertRaises(common.ExternalError, common.AppendGkiSigningArgs, cmd)
class InstallRecoveryScriptFormatTest(test_utils.ReleaseToolsTestCase):
"""Checks the format of install-recovery.sh.

View File

@ -23,8 +23,8 @@ import common
import test_utils
from sign_target_files_apks import (
CheckApkAndApexKeysAvailable, EditTags, GetApkFileInfo, ReadApexKeysInfo,
ReplaceCerts, ReplaceVerityKeyId, RewriteAvbProps, RewriteProps,
WriteOtacerts)
ReplaceCerts, ReplaceGkiSigningKey, ReplaceVerityKeyId, RewriteAvbProps,
RewriteProps, WriteOtacerts)
class SignTargetFilesApksTest(test_utils.ReleaseToolsTestCase):
@ -588,3 +588,52 @@ name="apex.apexd_test_different_app.apex" public_key="system/apex/apexd/apexd_te
'system/apex/apexd/apexd_testdata/com.android.apex.test_package_2.pem',
'build/make/target/product/security/testkey'),
}, keys_info)
def test_ReplaceGkiSigningKey(self):
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_key = 'release_gki_key'
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm = 'release_gki_algorithm'
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args = 'release_gki_signature_extra_args'
misc_info = {
'gki_signing_key_path': 'default_gki_key',
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'default_gki_algorithm',
'gki_signing_signature_args': 'default_gki_signature_args',
}
expected_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': 'release_gki_key',
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'release_gki_algorithm',
'gki_signing_signature_args': 'default_gki_signature_args release_gki_signature_extra_args',
}
ReplaceGkiSigningKey(misc_info)
self.assertDictEqual(expected_dict, misc_info)
def test_ReplaceGkiSigningKey_MissingSigningAlgorithm(self):
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_key = 'release_gki_key'
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm = None
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args = 'release_gki_signature_extra_args'
misc_info = {
'gki_signing_key_path': 'default_gki_key',
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'default_gki_algorithm',
'gki_signing_signature_args': 'default_gki_signature_args',
}
self.assertRaises(ValueError, ReplaceGkiSigningKey, misc_info)
def test_ReplaceGkiSigningKey_MissingSigningKeyNop(self):
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_key = None
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_algorithm = 'release_gki_algorithm'
common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_extra_args = 'release_gki_signature_extra_args'
# No change to misc_info if common.OPTIONS.gki_signing_key is missing.
misc_info = {
'gki_signing_key_path': 'default_gki_key',
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'default_gki_algorithm',
'gki_signing_signature_args': 'default_gki_signature_args',
}
expected_dict = {
'gki_signing_key_path': 'default_gki_key',
'gki_signing_algorithm': 'default_gki_algorithm',
'gki_signing_signature_args': 'default_gki_signature_args',
}
ReplaceGkiSigningKey(misc_info)
self.assertDictEqual(expected_dict, misc_info)